Follow us today…
When Vanessa went to buy her dream Tesla, the dealership swapped her clean car for an accident-damaged one—is this a hidden disaster or a deal worth the risk?
Vanessa Von Graff on the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y Owners Club Facebook page says,
“I’m supposed to pay for this car tomorrow. After leaving a deposit on another car with this dealership, they said that the car “got sent back,” if there’s such a thing as sending cars back when you buy them at auction. I think they sold it to someone else.”
“Then they tell me they’ve got another one like it, but then it turns out it’s not like it. This one actually has been in an accident. Is this car too damaged? Should I run to get it or run away from these liars?”
Immediate Red Flags and the Deposit Issue
The moment the dealership told Vanessa the original car was “sent back,” a huge red flag should have gone up when buying a Tesla from a non-Tesla dealership.
While cars can indeed be returned to auction houses if they fail to meet contractual conditions (e.g., undisclosed flood damage), the immediate pivot to an entirely different, previously undisclosed vehicle strongly suggests that the first car was sold for a higher profit.
Vanessa’s initial deposit now acts as leverage for them.
The takeaway is this: buyers must focus on safeguarding their deposit when dealing with any car dealership. Demand a clear, immediate timeline for its return, or use it as negotiating power for an independent inspection, but under no circumstances should you proceed with payment “tomorrow” until every concern is resolved.
The Accident Vehicle Risk
The fact that the replacement car is “not like it” and “has been in an accident” is the most crucial piece of information. This situation perfectly illustrates the warning signs of a bait-and-switch Tesla purchase by the dealership.
Modern Teslas are highly complex, structural components that often integrate the battery pack directly into the vehicle’s rigidity. Even a moderate accident, especially one involving side or undercarriage impact, can compromise the structural integrity, safety systems, or, most critically, the multi-thousand-dollar battery pack.
Advertising
There’s a tight deadline, so this is what you need to do right now.
- Demand the VIN (Vehicle Identification Number): If you don’t already have it, get the VIN immediately. Do not accept excuses.
- Get a Detailed Accident Report: A quick CARFAX or AutoCheck report is the bare minimum, but you need to go deeper. You need to know: Was it totaled? Was it a salvage title? What specific repairs were performed? The report is only as good as the reporting body, so be skeptical.
- Mandate a Professional Inspection: Before you pay a dime, you must insist on an independent, pre-purchase inspection (PPI) performed by a reputable third-party shop—ideally a shop that specializes in electric vehicles or body-on-frame aluminum structures. You should know how to check the accident history before buying a used Tesla Model 3 (or Model Y). A thorough PPI is the only way to get an accurate assessment.
The Cost of Accident Damage in EVs
In a traditional car, a fender-bender is often purely cosmetic. In a Tesla, damage can be deceptively expensive and catastrophic. When evaluating minor vs major Tesla accident damage repair costs, you must consider the advanced sensors, the structural integrity of the frame, and the state of the battery cooling system.
Even a minor alignment issue can damage tires or compromise Autopilot functionality, necessitating costly calibration. A car that has been “sent back” or subsequently replaced with a damaged unit is a massive risk.
In The End
While the Tesla owner club community advice for used car buyers often focuses on range and mileage, the single greatest piece of advice, especially in this scenario, is: walk away from compromised history unless you have iron-clad proof of professional, certified repair—and even then, residual value will suffer.
The dealership’s behavior has been dishonest and manipulative from the start, prioritizing a quick sale over your safety and financial well-being. This is not the foundation for a good purchase.
A Question For You
Would you risk buying an accident-damaged Tesla from a dealership that already swapped your reserved car and lied about its condition? Click the red Add New Comment link below and let us know.
Check out my Tesla Model 3 story: My 2022 Tesla Model 3 Has Lost So Much Value, I’m Trading It In For a 2025 Rivian R1S Tri, I’m About To Pull the Trigger, But I’m Scared
I am Denis Flierl, a Senior Torque News Reporter since 2012. My 30+ year tenure in the automotive industry, initially in a consulting role with every major car brand and later as a freelance journalist test-driving new vehicles, has equipped me with a wealth of knowledge. I specialize in reporting the latest automotive news, covering owner stories, and providing expert analysis, ensuring that you are always well-informed and up-to-date. Follow me on X @DenisFlierl, @WorldsCoolestRides, Facebook, and Instagram
Photo credit: Denis Flierl via Vanessa Von Graff
Follow us today…
Source: torquenews.com
