Follow us today…
She loves her new Tacoma pickup, but it turned sour after her fourth oil change at the dealer.
I found this detailed account from Carla Bandimere Brady, a new 4th Generation Toyota Tacoma owner, whose first year of ownership culminated in a service visit that left her “extremely frustrated and feeling discounted.” Her experience highlights several critical issues facing truck owners today, including unexpected service delays and charges, as well as the ongoing debate between aftermarket parts and dealership protocols.
First, let’s hear from Carla, and then dive into what happened and what Toyota customers need to know.
Carla, on the 4th Generation Toyota Tacoma Owners Group Facebook page, says,
“I love my Tacoma, but the dealer just ruined my ownership experience. I took it for its 4th oil change yesterday, had the recall taken care of, tires rotated, and the service campaign done. I’ve had it for one year today. They told me it would take seven hours to complete all that. Toyota called me at 4:30 last night and told me it would not be finished by closing time.”
“I asked the guy when he thought it would be done? He said 9:30 today, and he would send a shuttle after me between 10 and 11. I had to be at work by 9. I then received a call stating that my aftermarket Fumoto valve was leaking, and they would be happy to charge me $13 for an OEM drain plug. I told them if it was leaking, it was because of something they did, cause it wasn’t leaking when I brought it in.”
“Excuse me? You would have thrown that in for free if it were an OEM one on there.”
“They told me they had video of it leaking. I want to see that. There have been no leaks since I installed it. They sent me a picture. When I performed the oil change last time, I had a hard time removing the drain plug. Of course, when I got it, it dripped down my arm. I let it drain, grabbed a few paper towels, and went back in to put the Fumato on, then wiped the pan very quickly. It wasn’t leaking. It was residual and sand from my camping trip two weeks ago.”
“I am not a mechanic (obviously), and I trust the dealership, that is why I take it there. I don’t, however, want them to assume that they can charge me whatever they want just because.”
“I try to learn as much as I can about my truck, because I really do love it. I am extremely frustrated and feel so discounted. No one wants to be taken advantage of, and I wonder if I can ever trust them.”
Carla’s Positive Ownership Experience Goes South
It’s what happens when this Tacoma owner’s journey leads to the service bay, and the promise of reliable service turns into frustration and then mistrust.
Her story, shared on a popular Facebook page, serves as a cautionary tale for new Tacoma owners everywhere, highlighting potential pitfalls in the dealer’s service department and emphasizing the critical importance of clear communication and excellent customer service.
Carla’s first anniversary with her beloved Tacoma should have been a celebration. Instead, it culminated in a multi-day ordeal at her local Toyota dealership. She had scheduled a comprehensive service appointment that included her fourth oil change, a recall rectification, a tire rotation, and a service campaign.
The First Mistake: The Dealer Overpromised and Underdelivered
The dealership initially quoted a seven-hour turnaround time for these crucial maintenance tasks. While a full day in the shop is not uncommon for such an extensive list of items, the execution of the service quickly veered off course. As closing time approached, Carla received the unwelcome news: her truck wouldn’t be ready. The new estimated completion time stretched to 9:30 AM the following day, with a shuttle promised between 10 and 11 AM – a timeframe that unfortunately clashed with her work schedule, immediately adding stress to an already inconvenient situation.
This initial delay underscores a common frustration among customers dealing with Toyota Tacoma recall service campaign wait times, where scheduling and actual completion times often diverge.
The situation escalated dramatically when Carla received a call claiming that her aftermarket Fumoto oil drain valve was leaking, and the dealership was prepared to charge her $13 for an OEM drain plug replacement. This came as a significant shock to Carla, who adamantly stated that the valve “wasn’t leaking when I brought it in.” She correctly pointed out that if a leak had developed, it was likely due to something that occurred during the dealership’s handling of the oil change. Her indignation was understandable: “Excuse me? You would have thrown that in for free if it were an OEM one on there.”
Advertising
This exchange highlights a critical area of contention for many vehicle owners: the treatment of aftermarket parts during dealership service.
The dealership’s immediate impulse to charge for a part that may have been damaged or disturbed during their service raises serious questions about transparency and customer service. Carla’s experience provides a stark example of an aftermarket Fumoto valve leaking after an oil change at the dealership, a situation that can quickly erode customer trust.
The Dealer Documents the Problem
To bolster their claim, the dealership sent Carla a picture of the alleged leak and mentioned they had video evidence. Carla, however, was quick to contextualize the image. She recalled having a difficult time removing the drain plug during her last DIY oil change and admitted to some residual dripping onto her arm. She explained that after installing the Fumoto valve, she quickly wiped the pan, but acknowledged that residual oil combined with sand from a recent camping trip could easily be misinterpreted as an active leak.
This discrepancy between the dealership’s “evidence” and Carla’s plausible explanation creates a significant trust deficit. Her story serves as a valuable lesson on documenting vehicle condition before Toyota service visits, perhaps with quick photos or a visual inspection walk-around with the service advisor.
Carla’s profound statement, “I am not a mechanic (obviously) and I trust the dealership, that is why I take it there. I don’t, however, want them to assume that they can just charge me whatever they want just because,” perfectly encapsulates the core issue.
Minor issues can quickly escalate into major grievances.
Many Tacoma owners, like Carla, rely on dealerships for their specialized knowledge and certified technicians, expecting honest assessments and fair pricing. When that trust is challenged by what feels like an opportunistic upsell or a misdiagnosis, the relationship sours. She feels “taken advantage of,” a sentiment no customer should experience. Her ordeal serves as a case study in the new Toyota Tacoma’s service frustrations and customer trust, highlighting how minor issues can quickly escalate into major grievances.
There’s A Larger Problem
The dealership’s attempt to charge $13 for an OEM drain plug, despite its relatively low cost, is symbolic of a larger problem.
It’s not just about the money, but the principle of being charged for something that wasn’t an issue before the service was provided. This situation raises the question of how to dispute dealership overcharge for drain plug replacement or similar minor repairs. Consumers should always ask for detailed explanations, physical proof (not just a picture), and consider getting a second opinion if a repair recommendation feels suspicious.
Understanding consumer rights when a dealership claims new damage is crucial for navigating these challenging interactions. Had Carla been less observant or informed, she might have agreed to the charge, unknowingly paying for a problem that was either non-existent or created during the service itself. Dealerships have a responsibility not just to provide mechanical service, but also to excel in managing customer expectations in automotive service through clear, honest, and transparent communication.
Conclusion:
Carla’s ordeal at her Toyota dealership serves as a reminder that even with a brand as reputable as Toyota, the customer service experience can vary wildly. Her story isn’t just about a Fumoto valve or a drain plug; it’s about the erosion of trust when a routine service visit turns into an adversarial interaction.
Customers rely on the expertise of dealerships, but that reliance should never be mistaken for naiveté. Documenting your vehicle’s condition, understanding the scope of work, and being prepared to question unexpected charges are essential steps for any owner.
This isn’t about fostering distrust, but about promoting transparency and accountability. Dealerships, in turn, must recognize the immense value of maintaining customer trust and strive for clear, honest communication at every step of the service process. In the end, a happy customer like Carla, who truly loves her Tacoma, is the best advertisement any dealership can have. When that trust is broken, the ripple effects can be far-reaching, extending beyond a single service bay to the broader community of Toyota enthusiasts.
It’s Your Turn
Have you had a bad experience with a dealer? If so, click the red Add New Comment link below and let us know.
Check out this Toyota customer’s interaction with a Toyota dealer: The Toyota Dealer Quoted Me $1,500 to ‘Refresh’ My 2021 RAV4 Hybrid System, and Now, I’m Glad I Turned It Down Because It Was a Scam
I am Denis Flierl, a Senior Torque News Reporter since 2012. My 30+ year tenure in the automotive industry, initially in a consulting role with every major car brand and later as a freelance journalist test-driving new vehicles, has equipped me with a wealth of knowledge. I specialize in reporting the latest automotive news, covering owner stories, and providing expert analysis, ensuring that you are always well-informed and up-to-date. Follow me on X @DenisFlierl, @WorldsCoolestRides, Facebook, and Instagram
Photo credit: Denis Flierl via Carla Bandimere Brady
Follow us today…
Source: torquenews.com
